runit services on or off by default? antiX-22-full

Forum Forums antiX-development Development runit services on or off by default? antiX-22-full

  • This topic has 14 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated Sep 8-10:00 pm by techore.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #87936
    Forum Admin
    anticapitalista

      On installation, should the default be to have runit services on or off (essential ones will always be on)?

      On live boot, only these (essential) services are running:

      connman
      dbus
      getty-tty1-6
      seatd
      slimski
      udevd

      Technically, if connman is removed and ceni used instead, then we only *need*

      getty-tty1-6
      slimski
      udevd

      • This topic was modified 8 months ago by anticapitalista. Reason: added some more information

      Philosophers have interpreted the world in many ways; the point is to change it.

      antiX with runit - leaner and meaner.

      #87937
      Member
      calciumsodium
        Helpful
        Up
        2
        ::

        My preference is OFF.

        #87940
        Member
        ModdIt
          Helpful
          Up
          1
          ::

          Agree with calciumsodium.
          For those like me and students needing cups or others wanting redshift
          or maybe soon pipewire etc runit is easy to understand and setup.

          #87945
          Moderator
          Brian Masinick
            Helpful
            Up
            1
            ::

            Personal preference would be to keep the default services the same as the live image and potentially provide a single tool to enable, disabled and manage overall runit services (that would be an optional but useful feature to simplify management of runit services).

            Just my opinion; I don’t need any extras myself; first time users may appreciate a simple tool or tool chest.

            --
            Brian Masinick

            #87948
            Member
            marcelocripe
              Helpful
              Up
              1
              ::

              … first time users may appreciate a simple tool or tool chest.

              This is an excellent idea!
              It would be really nice to be able to have a GUI listing all services and next to a button for each service, allowing the user to enable or disable the respective service at antiX runit startup, something similar to the “runit-service-manager” feature (I never I saw the look of this program that I translated to pt-BR), it seems that “runit-service-manager” is already translated in some languages in Transifex.

              – – – – –

              … first time users may appreciate a simple tool or tool chest.

              Esta é uma ideia excelente!
              Seria muito bom poder ter uma interface gráfica listando todos os serviços e ao lado um botão para cada serviço, permitindo ao usuário ativar ou desativar o respectivo serviço na inicialização do antiX runit, algo semelhante ao recurso “runit-service-manager” (eu nunca vi a aparência deste programa que eu traduzi para pt-BR), ao que parece o “runit-service-manager” já está traduzido em alguns idiomas no Transifex.

              #87949
              Member
              blur13
                Helpful
                Up
                1
                ::

                Doesnt firefox depend on dbus?

                #87950
                Forum Admin
                anticapitalista
                  Helpful
                  Up
                  0
                  ::

                  Personal preference would be to keep the default services the same as the live image and potentially provide a single tool to enable, disabled and manage overall runit services (that would be an optional but useful feature to simplify management of runit services).

                  Just my opinion; I don’t need any extras myself; first time users may appreciate a simple tool or tool chest.

                  It already exists and is on the antiX-21 runit iso files. Xecure wrote a script called runit-service-manager.sh
                  It should be in the menu and control centre.

                  Philosophers have interpreted the world in many ways; the point is to change it.

                  antiX with runit - leaner and meaner.

                  #87951
                  Forum Admin
                  anticapitalista
                    Helpful
                    Up
                    0
                    ::

                    Doesnt firefox depend on dbus?

                    Yes …. and no…

                    Removing dbus will cause all sorts of issues since so many apps have it declared as a dependency.
                    Turning off dbus does not break firefox (or any other browser that depends on it) since firefox *forces* dbus to be active.
                    If you disable/rename/move all the dbus libs etc, firefox will still work, but it sends out error messages.

                    There is a post somewhere in this forum about disabling dbus

                    Philosophers have interpreted the world in many ways; the point is to change it.

                    antiX with runit - leaner and meaner.

                    #87954
                    Moderator
                    Brian Masinick
                      Helpful
                      Up
                      0
                      ::

                      Personal preference would be to keep the default services the same as the live image and potentially provide a single tool to enable, disabled and manage overall runit services (that would be an optional but useful feature to simplify management of runit services).

                      Just my opinion; I don’t need any extras myself; first time users may appreciate a simple tool or tool chest.

                      It already exists and is on the antiX-21 runit iso files. Xecure wrote a script called runit-service-manager.sh
                      It should be in the menu and control centre.

                      Excellent! I have been using the antiX 21 runit image for quite some time and I am happy with both the features and the performance.

                      --
                      Brian Masinick

                      #87957
                      Member
                      olsztyn
                        Helpful
                        Up
                        0
                        ::

                        On live boot, only these (essential) services are running:

                        It appears to me the listed services are the same list as currently in antiX-21 runit *elogind*-free. Is there any other difference planned in antiX-22 vs. antiX-21, except *elogind*-free will be default going forward?

                        Live antiX Boot Options (Previously posted by Xecure):
                        https://antixlinuxfan.miraheze.org/wiki/Table_of_antiX_Boot_Parameters

                        #87993
                        Member
                        marcelocripe
                          Helpful
                          Up
                          0
                          ::

                          It should be in the menu and control centre.

                          Yes, anticapitalista. The ideal would be to have it in the menu and in the control center, as it should be in the SysVinit version that has “Choose Startup Services” in the menu and in the control center.

                          – – – – –

                          It should be in the menu and control centre.

                          Sim, anticapitalista. O ideal seria ter no menu e no centro de controle, assim como deve ser na versão SysVinit que possui “Choose Startup Services” no menu e no centro de controle.

                          #88000
                          Forum Admin
                          anticapitalista
                            Helpful
                            Up
                            0
                            ::

                            It *is* in the menu and control centre (since antiX-21 runit).

                            Philosophers have interpreted the world in many ways; the point is to change it.

                            antiX with runit - leaner and meaner.

                            #88002
                            Moderator
                            Brian Masinick
                              Helpful
                              Up
                              0
                              ::

                              In the antiX Control Centre, Navigate to System, then Choose Startup Services. While I didn’t see them “Labelled” as runit, all of the services available are there, and they can be stopped, started, and managed from there.

                              Also, from the primary system menu (on my system it is on the task bar labelled antiX; this may vary, depending on which taskbar view is selected).
                              From there, select Applications —> System —> Choose Startup Services, or visit the Control Center from that menu; it’s there.

                              Thank you anticapitalista for clarifying this again for us.

                              --
                              Brian Masinick

                              #88008
                              Forum Admin
                              anticapitalista
                                Helpful
                                Up
                                0
                                ::

                                On live boot, only these (essential) services are running:

                                It appears to me the listed services are the same list as currently in antiX-21 runit *elogind*-free. Is there any other difference planned in antiX-22 vs. antiX-21, except *elogind*-free will be default going forward?

                                Correct. antiX-22 will not have many changes except it will default be elogind-free (runit and SysVinit versions).

                                Philosophers have interpreted the world in many ways; the point is to change it.

                                antiX with runit - leaner and meaner.

                                #88349
                                Member
                                techore
                                  Helpful
                                  Up
                                  0
                                  ::

                                  @anticapitlista, how is development of antiX 22 coming along?

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.